æŦč¨äēã¯ãããĸãŧãˇã§ãŗãåĢãŋãžãã
ãããĢãĄã¯ããĒãĒããĒã§ãã
ãŋãĒãããæ¯æĨãŽæįäŊããį˛ãããžã§ãã
ã§ãæãĢã¯ãæįãããŽããããŠããããĒãã¨æããã¨ããããžãããã
äģåã¯ãããĒæãĢčĒãŋããæŦãīŧåãį´šäģããžãã
čĒãã°ããŖã¨åŋãčģŊããĒãã¯ãã
ãæįããããŠãâĻãã¨æããĻããæšã¯ãã˛æåžãžã§ãčĒãŋãã ããã
ãŠãããĻãæįããããŠãããŽã

æįã¯æ¯æĨčĄãåŽļäēãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ã
ãæįãäŊãããģããĢãįŽįĢãčããããåžįäģããããããĒãŠãŋãšã¯ãå¤ãåŽļäēã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããããã
ãããĢæ é¤ããŠãŗãšãčããĒããéŖäēã፿ããâĻã
ããã䏿ĨīŧåčĄããĒããĻ大å¤ãĒäŊæĨã§ãã
įč
ã¯ãã¨ãã¨éŖãšããã¨ãģæįãäŊããã¨ãåĨŊãã§æ é¤åŖĢãŽčŗæ ŧãžã§äŋæããĻãããŽã§ãããæčŋããæããã§ãã
ãæ¯æĨãŽæįãĨããããããŠãâĻãã
ãåĨŊãã ãŖãæįããŠãããĻãããĒãĢãããŠããã ããīŧã
ãããĒãĸã¤ãĸã¤ãæąããįč
ãčĒãã§åčãĢãĒãŖãæŦãīŧåãį´šäģãããã¨æããžãã
čĒãã¨čŠãŽåãæããĻãŠã¯ãĢãĒããžããã
ãæŦåŊã¯ãã¯ããäŊããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽãĢããããŠããĒãŖãäēēããĄã¸ã

æåãĢãį´šäģãããŽã¯ãæŦåŊã¯ãã¯ããäŊããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽãĢããããŠããĒãŖãäēēããĄã¸ãã
æįį įŠļåŽļã§ãããŗãĻãąãŗãããããŽã¨ããģã¤ã§ãã
į§ãĢæããããĻãããŽãã¨æãŖãæŦãŽãŋã¤ããĢãčĻãĻčŋˇããæãĢåããžããã
æŦæ¸ã§ã¯ãŗãĻããããæįãã¤ãããŽããããŠããã¨æããäŊé¨ããã¨ãĢãčŦæŧäŧãããąå
ãåŽļåēã§ãŽčŠąãĒãŠãįļ´ãããĻããžãã
čĒãã ææŗ
čĒãã åžã¯å
ąæãããĒããŖãã§ãã
ãŗãĻããã¯īŧå ãŽįļã
ãåŽļåēã§ãŽãåããããĄã¨ãŽéŖãåˇĄãããã¨ããĢãããããããã¨é ˇããĒããčĒãã§ããžããã
ä¸ãŽãæ¯ããéãŽäģŖåŧãããĻãããĻããĻãæããįŽé ãįąããĒãæãã
æįãäŊããŽãįˇã§ãåĨŗã§ãæããã¨ã¯åãã ãŖãããããã§ããã

åč˛ãĻä¸ãŽæšã¯įšãĢåčãĢãĒãæŦã ã¨æããžãã
æŦæ¸ã§įč
ãå°čąĄãĢæŽãŖãč¨čãīŧã¤ãããžãã
īŧã¤ãã¯ãŗãĻããã2018åš´ãĢããŠãŗãšãĢåæãĢčĄãŖãéãŽåĨŗæ§ãŽä¸č¨ã
ãåŽļã§æįã°ããäŊãŖãĻããããį§ãŽãĩãŗãˇãŖã¤ãŗãčŧããĒããããĒãã
ãŗãĻãąãŗããčãæŦåŊã¯ãã¯ããäŊããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽãĢããããŠããĒãŖãäēēããĄã¸ãp.30
ãĄããŖã¨čĄæãåããžããã
åäēēä¸ģįžŠãŽããŠãŗãšäēēãããč¨čã§ãããã
ãããĒãĢč¨ãåãŖãĻããžããŽãããŖãããããããŽããããŽæčã§ãããŽããĒã¨č¨ąããããããĒæ°æãĄãĢãĒããžãã
īŧã¤ãã¯ææįīŧææ
īŧ(p.53)ãĢåēãĻãããŗãĻãããŽčãã§ãã
åŽã¯ããææįīŧææ ãŽãããĄãŧãŋãŧãã§ã¯ãĒããææįīŧäŊčŖãŽãããĄãŧãŋãŧãã¨čããæšããããŖãããããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããããã
ãŗãĻãąãŗããčããæŦåŊã¯ãã¯ããäŊããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽãĢããããŠããĒãŖãäēēããĄã¸ã p.54
ææįãĢåŋ čĻãĒãŽã¯ãåŋãŽäŊčŖãæéãŽäŊčŖã§ãã
ããããåãããŽããæšã¯ãģãŖã¨ããč¨čã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããããã
ããĄããå ¨é¨ãææįãããŽã¯į´ æ´ããããã¨ã§ãã
ã§ããåŽéã¯éŖããã§ãããã
ãį§ãŖãĻããĄãĒčĻĒâĻãã¨æãŖãĻããžãããĄãĒã¨ããããåŽã¯äŊčŖããĒãã ããĒãã ãã¨ãŗãĻãããæããĻãããžãã

æĨé æããĻãããĸã¤ãĸã¤ãĢį´åžãŽįããããããžããã
ãŗãĻããã¯æŦæ¸ã§æįãã¤ãããŽããããŠãįįąãĢãčĒåãŽįæŗãŽãããĢã¤ãŠã¤ãŠããĻããĒãããã¨æããĻããžãã
ãīŊããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã¨æãŖãĻããã¨ãčĒåãčĻãããĻããžããã¨ããããžãããã
čĒåãŽįæŗããã ãããĢãĒãŖãĻããĒãããäģä¸åēĻčããĻãŋãã¨ãããããããžããã

įšãĢå°ããåãŠããããã¨čĒåãŽæãéããĢãããã¨ãŽãģããå°ãĒãâĻã
ãžãåˇģæĢãĢã¯æéãæé¤ãããŦãˇããį´šäģãããĻããžãã
æŦæãĢįģå ´ãããŦãˇããåįã¤ãã§čŧãŖãĻããĻããã¯ãäŊããŽæéãå°ãĒããããĸã¤ããĸã¯åčãĢãĒããžãã
ãæŦåŊã¯ãã¯ããäŊããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽãĢããããŠããĒãŖãäēēããĄã¸ãã¯ãŗãĻãããŽåĒããčĒãåŖã§æįãŽäŊãæãĢå
ąæããĻãããžãã

ãæįäŊããĢį˛ããã¨ããæšããĢãã˛čĒãã§ããã ãããä¸åã§ãã
ããĄããŖã¨äŊãŖãĻãŋãããĒã大äēēãŽããããææããã¯ãã

æŦĄãĢãį´šäģãããŽã¯ããĄããŖã¨äŊãŖãĻãŋãããĒã大äēēãŽããããææããã¯ããã
åŽļåēæįį įŠļåŽļã§ããåĨĨčåŖŊåãããŽãŦãˇãæŦã§ãã
åĨĨčããã¯50äģŖãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããæįããããŠããããĒãã¨æãå§ããããã§ãã
ããŽįįąãĢäŊåãæ°åãå°ããã¤čŊãĄãĻãããã¨ãåč˛ãĻãã˛ã¨æŽĩčŊããĻåŧĩãåãããĒããĒãŖããã¨ãæããĻããžãã
åĨĨčãããŽäŊé¨ãĢåēãĨãããŦãˇããŽææĄãã¨ãĻãåčãĢãĒããžããã
čĒãã ææŗ
åįäģããŽããŧã¸ã°ãããĒãŽã§ãããŠããŠã¨ããããĒããčĒããžãã
įč ãå°čąĄãĢæŽãŖããŽã¯ãæã¯ãããããĒãããŠãäŊãĢããããŽã¯éŖãšããããã¨ããč¨čã
įšãĢéčã¯æããããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããããã

ãæŖčãå¤éŖãããããŠãéĢãã¤ããæ é¤į´ ãæ¸ãŖãĻããå ´åãã
čĒåã§äŊããŽãåįįããã
æŦæ¸ã§ã¯īŧã¤ãŽé
įŽåĨãĢãäŊãŖãĻãŋãããĒãããŦãˇããį´šäģãããĻããžãã
ãŠããäŊãæšã¯īŧīŊīŧãšãããã
ããæ°ãåēãĒãã¨ããŽãŦãˇãã¯īŧãšãããã§äŊãããŽã§æ§ãããĢæįãã§ããžãã
åĨĨčããã¯æŦæ¸ãŽä¸ã§ããč¨ãŖãĻããžãã
ã§ãæãŖããã§ããæŦåŊã¯æ°æãĄãŽåéĄãããĒãããŖãĻããģããŽãĄããŖã¨ãŽčãæšããããæšãåˇĨå¤ĢããããæŦåŊã¯ãããĒãĢ大å¤ãĒãã¨ãããĒããŽãããŖãĻã
åĨĨčåŖŊå ããĄããŖã¨äŊãŖãĻãŋãããĒã大äēēãŽããããææããã¯ãã p.3
ãŗãĻãąãŗãããããŽãčĒåãŽįæŗãŽãããĢã¤ãŠã¤ãŠããĻããĒãããã¨éããããŽããããããĢæããžãããīŧ
čĒåãŽä¸ã§éˇåš´åšãŖãĻãããããããĒããã°ãããĒããããããããšããããĄããŖã¨å¤ããã ãã§ãåŽã¯æįã大å¤ãããĒããĒããããããžããã

éˇåš´å ä¸ã§ããŖãããŽååããããĻããäēēããšãŠã¤ãĩãŧãäŊŋãŖãĻãŋãããããŖãããŽååãããŠã¯ãĢãĒããããããžããã
æŦæ¸ã§į´šäģãããĻããčąãããč¸ã(p.42)ã¯ãæįããããŠããããã¨ããĢãããããŽãŦãˇãã§ã(äŊåēĻãäŊãŖãĻãžã)ã
ãããããã¨ãããŽã°ãŠãŋãŗ(p.96)ããã˛äŊãŖãĻãŋããīŧã¨ãæįãĢį˛ããã¯ããããããããĻããįč
ãĒãŽã§ããã
ããĄããŖã¨äŊãŖãĻãŋãããĒã大äēēãŽããããææããã¯ããã¯æ°čģŊãĢäŊããåŽļåēæįãŽãŦãˇããããŖãąãã
æ¯æĨãŽæįãŽããŗããããããããããžããã
ãããŠãŗãšãŽå°æããåĻãļ大äēēãŽããããĢãŦãˇãã

æåžãĢãį´šäģãããŽã¯ãããŠãŗãšãŽå°æããåĻãļ大äēēãŽããããĢãŦãˇããã§ãã
ããĄããæįį įŠļåŽļã§ããä¸į°æˇŗåãããŽãŦãˇãæŦã
ä¸į°ããããåãããŽįŦįĢãä¸äēēãã¯ããŽæĨãåĸãããã¨ã§æįããããŠããĢæããããã§ãã
æŦæ¸ã§ã¯æĨæŦãŽéŖæã§äŊãããŠãŗãšįãĒãã¯ããŽãŦãˇããį´šäģãããĻããžãã
čĒãã ææŗ
éå ˇã˛ã¨ã¤ã§äŊãčĒŋįæŗãã¨ãĻãåčãĢãĒããžããã
â大äēēãŽâããããĢãŦãˇãã ãããŖãĻãåēãĻãããæįã¯ãŠããã¯ã¤ãŗãĢåãããã
æŦæ¸ã§ã¯ããŠãŗãšãŽåŽļåēæįãããŗããĢæ°č˛ ããĒãéŖäēãĨãããææĄããĻããžãã
ããŠãŗãšãŽãĻãŖãŧã¯ããŧãŽåŽļåēæįã¯ã¨ãĻããˇãŗããĢã§ãä¸č¨ãŽãããĢæéãæéããããããŖã¨äŊãããã§ãã
ãĒããĻé
åįãĒãŽâĻīŧ
į´šäģãããĻãããŦãˇãã¯ãģã¨ããŠīŧãšãããã
åˇĨį¨ãæ¸ããã¨ã§ãäŊããĒãããã¨ããããŦããˇãŖãŧãčģŊæ¸ãããžãã

į˛ããĻããĻããããŽããããĒãã§ãããã
åĄŠįŗæ°´(p.98)ãéļããčã§čŠĻããããããŖããåŗãæãŋãĻããĻæåããžããã
éčãŽčĒŋįæŗããããããã
ããããäŊããŽãæĨŊããŋã§ã(ãžãããããããĻã)ã
ãããŠãŗãšãŽå°æããåĻãļ大äēēãŽããããĢãŦãˇããã¯åŋ čĻæäŊéã§æįãæĨŊããŋãåŗãããã大äēēãĢãããããŽæŦã§ãã
ããããĢ

äģåã¯ãæįããããŠããæãĢčĒãŋããæŦãīŧåãį´šäģããžããã
ãããæįãåĨŊãã§ããæįãããããĒãæã¯ããã
æįį įŠļåŽļãŽæšããĄã§ãæįããããŠããĒãã¨ãããŽã¯ãĒãã ãåŽåŋããžããã
åŽļåēå
ãĢæįãŽäŊãæãä¸äēēãŽå ´åãããŽãããŠãã¯ãĒããĒãįč§ŖããĻããããĒããããããžããã
ãããĒæã¯æŦãĢãããŠããå ąæããĻããããžãããã
å
ąæãåžããã¨ã§čĒåãŽåŋãŽãąãĸãĢãã¤ãĒããã¨æããžãã

čĒåãŽæŠåĢã¯čĒåã§ã¨ãâĒ
äģåãį´šäģããæŦã¯ãŠããį´ æĩãĒæŦãĒãŽã§ãčåŗãŽããæšã¯ãã˛ãæãĢåãŖãĻãŋãĻãã ãããã
ããŽč¨äēãæĨã ãŽæįäŊããŽããŗããĢãĒãã°åš¸ãã§ãã
æåžãžã§ãčĒãŋããã ããããã¨ãããããžããã

















ãžããĢãŋã¤ããĢéããĒãŽ‼